Հինգշաբթի, մայիսի 26, 2016 Ժամանակը Երեւանում 12:41

    in English

    Oskanian Defends ‘Madrid Principles’

    Vartan Oskanian, Armenia’s former longtime foreign minister, has defended the most recent international plan to end the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict and warned that its blanket rejection could make the mediators reconsider their apparent acceptance of continued Armenian control over the disputed territory.

    Armenia -- Former Foreign Minister Vartan Oskanian.
    Armenia -- Former Foreign Minister Vartan Oskanian.

    In an extensive weekend interview with RFE/RL, he insisted that the basic principles of the Karabakh settlement that were formally put forward in Madrid in November 2007 are “incomparably” more favorable for the Armenian side than any of the peace proposals made by the U.S., Russian and French mediators in the past.

    “Whereas in the past we were offered at worst a high degree of [Karabakh’s] autonomy within Azerbaijan and at best horizontal ties between Azerbaijan and Karabakh within the framework of a common state, the Madrid principles … provide for the self-determination of the Nagorno-Karabakh people, which obviously means Nagorno-Karabakh’s independence or reunification with Armenia,” said Oskanian.

    “I am convinced that if we let slip this recognition of the Nagorno-Karabakh people’s right to self-determination, it will be very difficult to gain it again in the future and the negotiations could go in a totally different direction and they could start upholding [Azerbaijan’s] territorial integrity,” he said. “Today we have an advantage over Azerbaijan in terms of the upholding of this [self-determination] principle. That is why I think we should be careful in our statements, our criticisms and should pick the right target.”

    The so-called Madrid principles, which the conflicting parties started discussing years before November 2007, envisage a phased resolution of the Armenian-Azerbaijani conflict that would start with a gradual liberation of the districts in Azerbaijan proper partly or fully occupied by Karabakh Armenian forces during the 1991-1994 war. In return, Karabakh would retain a land corridor to Armenia and be able to determine its final status in a future referendum.

    Like his predecessor Robert Kocharian, President Serzh Sarkisian appears to have essentially accepted this peace formula. According to the American, French and Russian diplomats co-chairing the OSCE Minsk Group, Sarkisian and his Azerbaijani counterpart Ilham Aliyev made significant progress in face-to-face meetings held this year and could iron out their remaining differences before the end of this year.

    The prospect of a breakthrough in the Armenian-Azerbaijani talks has prompted serious concern from Armenian nationalist groups opposed to major territorial concessions to Baku even in return for international recognition of Karabakh’s secession from Azerbaijan. The largest of them, the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (Dashnaktsutyun), has warned that it will campaign for Sarkisian’s resignation if he signs up to the Madrid principles.

    Oskanian dismissed the hardliners’ position, saying that no peaceful settlement is possible without the return of most of the Armenian-controlled territories surrounding Karabakh. “If the Armenian side wants to exclude the issues of return of territories, return of [Azerbaijani] refugees from future principles and be guided by the principle of ‘not a single inch of land to the enemy,’ which would be a wonderful solution, then Armenia or Nagorno-Karabakh or both of them should pull out of the negotiations,” he said. “If we are to negotiate, these principles will always be on the table.”

    The Madrid principles have also been rejected by some leading members of the main opposition Armenian National Congress (HAK). The alliance’s top leader, former President Levon Ter-Petrosian, was forced to resign in 1998 because of his vigorous advocacy of a similar peace accord drafted by the Minsk Group co-chairs in 1997. It too called for Armenian withdrawal from at least six of the seven occupied Azerbaijani districts but contained no mechanisms for determining Karabakh’s status, the main bone of contention.

    Some of Ter-Petrosian’s close associates say that the 1997 deal is better than what the mediators have proposed to Kocharian and Sarkisian. In particular, they claim that under that plan the occupied lands would not necessarily be placed back under Azerbaijani control after the Armenian pullout from them.

    Oskanian, who served as foreign minister from 1998-2008, insisted that in 1997 the international community sought Karabakh’s eventual return under Azerbaijani rule and came to terms with its de facto independence only during Kocharian’s presidency. “Sometimes we are driven by revenge and don’t think before saying and doing something,” he said in a clear reference to the Ter-Petrosian camp.

    Oskanian argued that instead of rejecting the Madrid document out of hand, Armenian opposition forces should focus on its crucial details. “Today their task must be to clarify what the bar set by the authorities is,” he said. “Our bar was set high. I have many doubts about today’s bar,” he added, exposing fears that Sarkisian is ready to make more concessions to Azerbaijan than Kocharian was.

    The Minsk Group co-chairs said last week that they are working on an “updated version” of the Madrid document to increase chances of its acceptance by Baku and Yerevan. It is not yet clear just how significant the changes made by them are.

    Speaking in RFE/RL’s Yerevan studio, Oskanian also reaffirmed his criticism of Sarkisian’s conciliatory policy towards Turkey that has earned the latter plaudits in the West but has not produced any tangible results so far. “Turkey has gotten from this Turkish-Armenian process what it wanted,” he said. “The Armenian side has not gained anything yet.”

    Oskanian, who set up last year a private think-tank called Civilitas, was unimpressed by Sarkisian’s recent announcement that he will not travel to Turkey this October for the return match of the two countries’ national football unless Ankara takes “real steps” to reopen the Turkish-Armenian border. He said Sarkisian should have made a more explicit linkage between the visit and an open border.

    “He left the window open,” the Syrian-born ex-minister said. “I think that’s what the Turks want … I just don’t know when our authorities will finally realize that the Turkish side is exploiting the process. They should have realized that a long time ago.”

    Ֆորումը փակված է:
    Մեկնաբանությունները
    Մեկնաբանություններ
         
    gaytzag palandjian , : MNer-Ispanya-Yerevan
    30.08.2009 01:20
    +0 / -0
    Ays artiv meganbanutyun nergayacri ourish gayk-ejeri vra.1997-in NK After Lisbon mi grutyamb wor luys undzayvec Hay Gyank shabatatertoum.Hagirch,Ayl darberag er da zor nman mi conflict i nman ayn e Ispanyo yev Francia 200 dari grvaxncor er Andorra-n i vercho goxmer hamadzynutyan yegan garavarelu miasnabar,zayn gochelov &quot;Principality of Andorra&quot;-Prinipat D&#193;ndorr.Ban@ nranoum e wor iraganutyan mej aveli Ispanagan(Catalu&#241;a-n e ayndex araj kshoum ir ouzacenr-bnagchutyan jaxjaxich metzmasnutyun nouynbdes Catalan(Ispanaciner) en..Aryeres garavarvoum e Ipr naxagah ounenalov mishd Francio Naxagahn isk Seu D&#250;rgell-i(Catalu&#241;na) ARkepiscopos-Ipr pox naxagah..YEV GAREVORAGUYN, AZAD AREVDRI GODI HAYDARARVADZ-Free Trade Zone..isk hargeli paron Oskanian yerp yes ayd ei bndoum copia ner ouxargelov Haratch i yev ayl Hay terteri, mejdex haencin inch wor im bolorovin chi hishadagvadz Gxzi -ch&#180;gides wor Ovgianoum anounn isk anhayd..yev ays bes Xachadzevecin im &quot;Suggedstion&quot;- mejdex drvadz@<br />Garevofraguyn..TURKIA YERPEK TOUYL CHI DALU -DEM E GNALU NK I ANGAXUTYAN UNTUNMAN YEV NOUYNISK ZINAGANOREN OKNELU E ADRBEJANIN YETE BADERAZM DZAKI.MIUS GOXMIC AREVMDAYAN-HADGABES ANGLO AMERIGIAN KARYUXAYIN UNGERUTYUNNER NECUK UNENALOV YURYANC GARAVARUTYUNNER.NRANK YEVS CHEN HAMADZAYNVI WOR METZ TURKIA-ADDRBEJANuntunen ARtsakh angaxutyun..ISK MENK SHAD BAN G&#168;SHAHENK ARTSAKH untunelov 3/4, gam azeri badgamvorner nerga Parliament i mej ou toxnenk hamadzaynvenk paxsdagannerin veradarc , arnvaz fizouli jabrail.Agda, meronk el veradarnan Shaumyan..SABES METZ TUKIO IXDZ PAPAG METDZABEDAGAN IR PARK@ bahelov i des ashkharhi wor Hayer chi hajoxecin ARtgsakh bahel ipr Angax bedutyun(IRAGANI MEJ IRENK(voch ouxagioren untunelov mer badgamavorneri,und worum parliament ner metdzmasnutyan garavaroum) ou nayev darackneri toxum inchbes wor e hima.Ayn e Karvajar ,lachin inchbes wor gan...SHESHD@ DNELOV &quot;free trade zone&quot; YEV IRAGANOREN AYD GORCADRELU.DESEK ANDORRAN 10 ANKAM AVELI GRGNABADEL E I R DNDESUTYUN SHNORHIV AYD GARKAVIJAKI.CHI TOXNELOV WOR VOCH FRFANCIA YEV VOCH ISPANYA &quot;lOOSE FACE&quot; YERES GORCNEN..yergousdek en da garavaroum ..yev grvanxncor che aylyevs.iragani mej BUINESS...AHA AYS E OUZOUM AYSOR VA TE YEREVANTSIN GHARABAGCIN SPURLAHAY YEV HAMAYN ASHKHARCH.HEDO CHE MORANAL WOR MINCHEV YERP BIDI AYS YERG AZGER TSHNAMI LINEN MIMIANTZ HED..LEZU GDNELU MIAG MIJOC AYD DZEVI DAG BAVARAREL YERGOUSDEK YEV KAXEL OKUD...shad ban ga anelik anshusht yev CHI NAYAC VEROHISHYAL AGHERFS IS--MISHD &quot;Dgen&quot; inchbes bidi aser gavaracin gazm ou badrasd linel yete...negnutyamb vodndzgutyan gnan noka..-.BAYC CHEM GARCOUM DA LINI NRANK EL EN OUZOU BIZNES...isk toxnel worosh harcer ar wor ang e.asel e Shushu masin chi xosel noca chi grgrelu, yev nman xntirner.ayl mishd azad zonna -shad chnchin maxayin dourk GIRAREL MOUDZVOX ARDADZVOX ABARANC.INCHBES ANDORRA -i dzevn e YEV ARAJANOUM E NAYEV TOURISM OV. sAHMANI VRA MI GOXMUM fRANCIACIK EN , MIU..iSPANACIK IRENC nerkin harcerin irenk en hasnoum.yete g&#180;cangak indz grecek dzez garox em aveli manramasn ys artiv dexegacnel..<br />Turkia-MN er yev Anglia yerpek chem garcoum veronshyal regime i hagaragen kanzi YERES CHEN GORCNOUM..unthagarak amracnoum en..Isk mer BOUN XNTIR MISHT YEXEL E YEV G&#180;MNA TZEGHASBANUTYAN JANACOUM-HADOUCOUM SAGAYN AYS XNTROUM YEVS TOXEK WOR SPYURK ARAJADAR LINI MENK ENK &quot;mNATZORTAS&quot; I DEM aSHKHARHI HANRUTYAN.hAYSTANCIN IR HOXI VRA E BIDI ARAARGI jAPONACIN fINLANDZCIN..pONYILL@ AVELI MEXM MODECUM h.hANRABEDUTYUNIC AYS HARCI VERABERYAL YEV TOXUNK WOR KRDAGAN HARC AVELI hasunna..mnam,<br />Hamahaigagani SIRO,<br />dzerd,<br />Azgi dzara,gaytzag palandjian www.ARMENIDAD-worldwide.org yev im 3 ejanoc zegouyc@ 4.5 dari H.Hanrabedutyan gayk eji vra er inch veraberoum e SPYURKI VERAGAZMAVORMAN.INCHU AYDEX CHE AYL